Stars: 4 out of 5
Pros: Decent mystery; plenty of fun
Cons: Typical Hallmark cheese; lots of changes from the
novels
The Bottom Line:
Hit and run; murder
In film with changes from books
Cheesy yet still fun
I Won’t Keep Mum About This Fun New Hallmark Movie Franchise
Since Hallmark Movie and Mystery seems to be making movies
out of many cozy mystery book franchise, I have to watch them. After all, it is one of my favorite genres,
right? Sunday night saw the debut of a
new franchise for them, Flower Shop
Mystery, with Mum’s the Word. I really enjoyed myself while watching it.
After becoming a widow and losing interest in her profession
as a lawyer, Abby Knight (Brooke Shields) has returned to her small home town
and opened up a flower shop that she runs with her best friend, Nikki Bender
(Kate Drummond). It also means getting to
spend more time with her father, retired detective Jeffrey (Beau Bridges). It’s a quiet life, but one she is enjoying.
That is until one day when Abby’s car is hit by a car
speeding out of an ally. The car takes
off, and she only gets a partial license plate.
Then comes the news that a murder happened in that ally. Could the car that hit Abby have held the
murderer? Working with the handsome
former PI who now owns the bar next door, Marco (Brennan Elliot), Abby intends
to find out.
I have several books in this series, but I’ve only read the
first three, and that’s been a while ago.
It’s not that I didn’t like the books, but so many other books keep
jumping off my TBR mountain range at me.
As a result, I didn’t catch the many changes made from the books that my
friends who do like the series have pointed out. Things like where Abby lives (apartment vs.
house), characters who were cut out, her description (short and red haired). I did catch a big one since Abby in the books
is significantly younger than she is here and never married. I just had to let that go when I sat down to
watch this film. Many fans of the book
are upset by the numerous changes, however, so if you are a fan of the books,
be prepared for them before you start watching this.
As I stated earlier, I did enjoy this film. The mystery was good, and as bits and pieces
of it came back to me, I think that part was fairly faithful to the book. Even so, I wasn’t completely sure what was
going on until the movie ended despite the limited number of suspects. Yet the conclusion was perfectly logical and
wonderfully executed. The characters we
did get were fun, and some of the lines between Marco and Abby made me chuckle
if not outright laugh.
Of course, the typical Hallmark movie cheese comes into
play, both from the acting and the writing.
You just have to accept that it will be there going into the film, and
you’ll be able to enjoy it.
Flower Shop Mystery:
Mum’s the World is a fun, light cozy mystery movie. And since that’s all it set out to be, it
succeeds brilliantly. Fans of the genre
will enjoy it, but fans of this particular book series will have to forget the
book to be able to enjoy it.
Looking for the movie on DVD? It's part of the Flower Shop Mysteries 3 Movie Collection.
Looking for more information on the book? Here's my review of this book in the series.
Looking for the movie on DVD? It's part of the Flower Shop Mysteries 3 Movie Collection.
Looking for more information on the book? Here's my review of this book in the series.
I just came across this yesterday and am looking forward to watching it. I love that the Hallmark Channel is doing movies based on books!
ReplyDeleteI'm quite obviously enjoying them as well. You'll have to get past the great liberties they took with this one, but I still really enjoyed it.
DeleteI recorded it thanks to your tip last week about these cozy movies. Haven't had a chance to watch it yet, but enjoyed the Aurora Teagarden ones I saw.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad you're enjoying the movies you've watched. Hope you enjoy this movie when you see it.
DeleteI'm okay with them making Abby an older, widowed, mother of a grown child. I'm also so nitpicking about various minor changes (type of car, law school grad rather than dropout, etc.). What is most disappointing is what, or rather who, is missing. No Molly? No Grace? No "Mad Mo" or cousin Jillian? They're a big part of what makes the series so special. If I can remember to separate the movies from the books, though, I can enjoy them. It was a fun movie to watch, and I'll give the next installment a chance.
ReplyDeleteI hear you. I'm still hoping they work Hannah's youngest sister into those movies somehow.
Deletewhy was it necessary to change everything in the book? faithful readers of Kate Collins books are so disappointed that the wonderful cast of charactors in the books are changed so completely.None of the people in the movie represent those in the books except maybe Marc who is too short for the 50 something abby and many of the people in the book were left out. If there are more of of favorite books being filmed, please let us know if they are going to be ruined by the casting.
ReplyDeletethe Hannah Swensen and Arorah Teagarden movies followed the books very well, with their families, friends and settings that copied the ones in the books. The movie left all of this out. Brooke Shields is too old to play Abby and the settings of her home, shop and Marco's bar are all wrong.Abby's Mother and the ladies who work in her shop, her family and friends are what make The Flowershop Mysteries so much fun to read.If anymore of this type of books are made into movies I hope readers like me won't be as disappointed as I am. Stick to the stories like the Hannah and Roe books.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you. There is too much left out in the movies that was in the books.
DeleteI've not read the books. I just think the casting could have been better. The male lead is clearly much younger than the lovely Brooke Shields.
ReplyDeleteI love the Hallmark movies, except for Brooke Shields and Kelly Martin. Brooke has never been a good actress and Kelly Martin is wooden. Hallmark should give one of these shows to Teri Polo and cancel the other one.
ReplyDeleteI am disappointed in a few things. I love Brooke, but she is too old to play the part of Abby. Abby was straight from college and is a short redhead with freckles! Her father was in a wheelchair. She has a cousin Jillian who is interesting.
ReplyDelete