Monday, November 16, 2026

Book Review: Murder in the Upper Crust by Mindy Quigley (Deep Dish Mysteries #6)

Stars: 4 out of 5
Pros: Creative murder with some characters we love
Cons: Pacing early on, missing many of the regulars
The Bottom Line:
Murder on retreat
A creative mystery
But missed regulars




Meditating on Murder

A trope of the cozy mysteries is the ex we’ve never met coming to town to disrupt life.  While we get the ex in town in Murder in the Upper Crust, the sixth in the Deep Dish Mysteries by Mindy Quigley, any fan of the series would know there’s a twist to it.

You see, when we first met Delilah O’Leary, the owner of a deep dish pizza restaurant in a resort town in Wisconsin, she was engaged to Sam Van Meter, and he was living in town.  But the two broke up, and Delilah has moved on.  Now, Sam is back, with his new girlfriend, SilverMoon.  In fact, SilverMoon and her father are turning a property on the lake into a retreat center.  The first retreat that are hosting is for wellness expert Rhianna Frost.  Rhianna’s assistant is Willow, the new girlfriend of Delilah’s best friend and sous chef, Sonya.  So, when the caterer for the event cancels at the last minute, Delilah finds herself being voluntold to take over in feeding the guests.

As a way of showing thanks for taking on the last-minute gig (in addition to being paid), Delilah is invited to participate in the first evening’s events, which include a guided meditation in some personal pods.  But when it is all over, one of the guests is dead.  Delilah has seen some weird things, so she is quick to think it was murder.  Given her access to the members of the retreat, and the fact that her boyfriend, Detective Calvin Capone, is also already part of the group, Delilah is asked to see if she can learn any more.  Will she figure out what happened?

One thing I love about this series is that we’ve gotten some unique methods of murder.  That holds true again here.  Is it potentially overly complicated to be realistic?  Yes.  Do I care?  Not in the slightest because it makes for a great novel.  I bought into it while I was reading because I was caught up in the story.

Now, if you are concerned because you had trouble following all the relationships in the first paragraph of my teaser, you don’t need to.  The book takes more than a paragraph to introduce everyone and set up relationships.  On the other hand, it does make for a bit of a slower start to the mystery.  But the suspense and the complications keep building, and the third act was hard to put down.  When we reached the end, everything made perfect sense.

And yes, the police asking Delilah to help isn’t realistic.  I bought it in this case, but I’m also reading about a gourmet pizza restaurant owner who has already solved five murders.  I am willing to give cozies lots of leeway when it comes to things like this since I enjoy them so much.

I had liked Sam when we first met him, so I was happy to see him come back.  I still really like him, and I appreciated the dynamic he added to the book.  On the other hand, we don’t see as much of most of the regulars as I would have liked.  Their absence was explained, but I missed them outside their brief cameos.

But the returning characters we did get?  I was happy to spend more time with them and watch as their characters and relationships continued to grow.  I am especially liking watching Delilah mature from book to book.  And the new characters were all strong.

We get four recipes at the end, only one of which is for pizza.  As always, they sound delicious.

Murder in the Upper Crust is another fun, creative serving.  I recommend ordering your favorite pizza and settling down for another visit with Delilah.

Enjoy another slice of murder with the rest of the Deep Dish Mysteries.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Thanks for stopping by. In order to combat spam, I moderate most comments. I'll get to your comment as soon as I can.