Searching the Smoke for the Truth
I’ve followed Lee Goldberg’s career from his days writing tie-ins to his new books following characters in the LA Sheriff’s Department. Along the way, his books have started to slip from the list of things I always enjoy. They aren’t bad, they just as good as they used to be. Hidden in Smoke, this third in his Sharpe and Walker series, is a perfect example.
If you are new to this series, Walter Sharpe is a brilliant arson investigator working for the LA Sheriff’s Department. Andrew Walker is his partner, a former US Marshall who has taken the job for something safer so he will be around for his family. Not that it always turns out that way. Still, Walker is beginning to pick up the skill needed for his new job even if he misses the more action-oriented parts of his old job.
When this book opens, West Hollywood has been rocked by a series of arsons in one night. The arsonist hit multiple apartment buildings by setting fire to a car in a car port. Just as the partners are beginning to piece some key clues together, a major fire impacts the city. Will this new fire distract them? Or will they be able to solve it as well?
There is actually a very strong second storyline that includes some major spoilers for the first book. Since it is introduced first, those spoilers start almost from the first page.
And, it’s actually with this second storyline that I want to start. There are some tie ins with the main storyline, but on the whole, it really could have been its own story. It adds little to the overall mystery and the flashback portions to tell this part of the story just slow things down. I was very bothered by aspects of this story since it involved targeting a medical company CEO. Maybe it’s just bad timing with the headlining murder that’s been in the news in the last few months, but it felt more political than the fun mystery/thriller I was looking forward to when I picked up this book. It’s obvious that Lee Goldberg wanted to write a caper, but it felt forced into this book.
On the other hand, the main mystery was fantastic with plenty of twists and turns to keep me engaged. I was surprised by several things along the way, but they all made sense to me as they happened.
The characters are a mixed bag. They are real enough to make us care about the outcome, but they feel a bit flat overall. The teenage boy humor we get at times certainly doesn’t help. This also really hurts the second storyline I was talking about earlier. They are some of the flattest characters.
On the other hand, there are some fun laughs and great banter between the characters.
Fans of Lee’s other current series will be interested to note that Eve Ronin and her partner Duncan Pavone show up part way through. There are some supporting characters between the two series as well. If you haven’t read Eve’s books, you won’t miss too much, but a few references will fly over your head.
Since I live in LA County, I enjoy all the references to places I know as I’m reading this book. I especially enjoy a few scenes that take place close to me. I was smiling as I followed the action, picturing exactly what I was talking about.
As you can see, Hidden in Smoke was a mixed bag. Fans of Lee’s books will enjoy it, but I do wish it were stronger overall.