In the Hands of the Fans? Maybe, Sort of…
I was all in during the buildup to season 50 of Survivor. After all, I’ve missed one episode of the show since it premiered 26 years ago (stupid VCR malfunction). But, I’ve got to say, while I enjoyed it, this wasn’t the celebration of the series that I was hoping for.
The season featured all returning players from many of the 49 previous seasons. The show started out with 24 constants, which is the largest cast they had featured yet. And here’s the first time I am going to contradict myself. I felt like they could have had more players from older seasons. Yes, they did have someone from season one, but they had too many from the new era, in my opinion, including two from season 49. At the same time I’m saying they needed more of a certain type of player, they had too many players to starts with. 24 players and 26 days means they have to cut people constantly. Several episodes featured twists that involved multiple people being voted out on the same night and in smaller groups. That’s not my choice at all.
Speaking of choices, during the airing of season 48, fans were given the chance to vote on multiple things, including the color of buffs, design of the immunity necklace, supplies, twists, etc. All the twists went the way we’ve been seeing in the new era. I get it, we need some of these twists and idols to keep the show from being too predictable. But, wouldn’t it have been fun to have a twist were there weren’t twists? That would really keep everyone on their toes.
The bones of the show are the same as always. We start with three tribes of eight survivors playing challenges to win rewards or immunity, then each week, at least one person is voted out of the game. Eventually, the tribes merge, and the people voted out form the jury that vote on who wins the game.
This was definitely not a season to jump into since it featured all returning players. There are backstories from their previous times in the game that factor into how they play and their thoughts on some of the other players. Additionally, there are just so many people to keep straight at the beginning that it helps if you have some idea who they are. Even then, I’ll admit I’d forgotten who a lot of them are, but it did come back relatively quickly.
Then there were the celebrity fans. If I had to hear “Billie Eilish Boomerang Idol” one more time…. Two celebrities showed up on the island and didn’t add much to the proceedings with their presence.
And really, there were so many twists it was hard for anyone to have a strategy. Yes, I get that it keeps the show from getting too predictable, but there needs to be a balance, and the show went in the wrong direction here.
On the other hand, it was nice to see some of my favorites playing again. And the players pulled off some fun things given the parameters they had to work with (you know, the too many twists).
Yes, fans will still mostly enjoy season 50 of Survivor. Despite my critiques, I did enjoy it. But I hope they pull things back for the seasons airing soon (not that it sounds like they plan to).










