“We Are Going Back to High School.”
I was a bit surprised when I saw that we were getting a second True Justice movie on Hallmark. Then again, I was also surprised to find that it had been two and a half years since the first one aired. Somehow, I was thinking it had been longer. Anyway, we revisited these law student detectives in Eye for an Eye.
For them, it’s been a few months since the four friends cleared Casey’s (Katherine McNamara) brother of murder. They’ve been filling their time with true crime shows and their school work when Liam (Alexander Nunez) finds them another case. Seems that a parent association in a small town about half an hour away has erupted into murder. The president was killed, and another mom has been convicted of the crime. But as the friends start looking into things, they find evidence that makes them think justice hasn’t been served. Can they figure out what really happened?
There was one thing that bothered me. It was small. But it kept driving me crazy. The murder happened three months before our characters got involved. The body was found in the snow. During that time, the trial had already taken place. Granted, right there, that is very fast. But it was just as snowy in the present day as it was during the flashbacks. Now, granted, I don’t live where in snows, but the characters (and production) acted like it was a few weeks at most instead of months.
I do wish we’d had a bit more of a reintroduction to the characters in this movie. The assumption was made that we remember exactly who everyone was. Now, I could have rewatched the first movie, but I didn’t, so it has been almost two and a half years since I met the characters. I think I got everyone and their relationships figured out as the movie went along, however.
The mystery itself was good. There were enough suspects to keep me engaged. The characters’ attempts to gather evidence was fun without being too cartoonish. Realistic? No. But I’m not watching these movies for realism. The ending made sense, and I liked how the subplot wrapped up.
The acting was decent as well. If you are familiar with Hallmark movies, you’ll know what to expect here, and you’ll be able to get lost in the story. I should mention that Hallmark staples Benjamin Ayres and Nikki DeLoach reprise their supporting roles. And Nikki DeLoach helped write the movie once again.
It was nice to revisit the True Justice characters with Eye for an Eye. I hope if we get a third movie, it doesn’t take as long to get to us.









