Stars: 3 out of 5
Pros: Fun songs and dance numbers, great production,
nostalgia
Cons: The moral of the story
The Bottom Line:
50’s nostalgia
Great song, dance numbers ruined
By shaky moral
There Was a Reason I Had Been Avoiding This Musical
There is a long list of classic American musicals I had
never seen or hadn’t seen until the last few years. One of those was Grease. I’d avoided it
because of some of what I’d heard about the storyline. But I couldn’t pass when I saw that Fox was
joining the live musical bandwagon and producing Grease Live! With people I
am familiar with in the cast, I figured this was as good a time as any to watch
the movie. Sadly, it was pretty much
exactly what I was expecting.
The musical takes up back to 1959 and tells the story of
Sandy (Julianne Hough) and Danny (Aaron Tveit), high school seniors who had met
the summer before on the beach. They
figure they are going their separate ways until Sandy’s family moves from Salt
Lake City and she attends a new school, the school where Danny just happens to
go.
Of course, they can’t just get back together. Sandy’s a good girl with strict parents. Danny’s a greaser. Sandy makes friends with a group of girls
lead by Rizzo (Vanessa Hudgens), who seems to have a bit of a crush on
Danny. Will their very different
backgrounds keep them from making their relationship work in the real world?
I can certainly see the appeal of the musical. Even today, 1950’s nostalgia is strong, and
it was certainly strong in the 1970’s, when this musical was first
written. The music is fun, and the
dancing is top notch. This is an example
of the best in the genre from that standpoint.
And NCB could learn a thing or two from the production
here. Yes, it was all done on
soundstages live, but that didn’t mean it was anything less than glorious. The costumes and the sets were both
wonderful. The effects shots, pretty
much reserved for a drag race late in the movie, were top notch. This was a huge step up from the three NBC
efforts. There are also some awesome
costume changes that compare to the best of Broadway.
Likewise, the acting was better. Oh, I’m not comparing it to any of the
performances from the classic movie since I’ve never seen that. Again, I’m comparing it to the NBC live shows
we’ve gotten so far, which have featured acting that can be a bit stiff. And it was a blast watching the cast, which
included such people as Boys II Men, Carlos PanaVega, and even Eve Plumb as the
female mechanics teacher at the school.
I felt everyone did a great job.
I think one different was the live audience, which gave the
performers someone to react against. Of
course, it was a double edged sword when they used the audience as part of the
action. For some scenes it work, but for
others, it left me scratching my head.
One scene in particular with two sets of bleachers on front lawn of the
school springs immediately to mind in the head scratcher category.
No, my issues with the movie are more with the story. First, there’s the question of the
timeline. I guess the story takes place
over the course of a school year, but it felt to me like maybe a month had
passed at most. Either I didn’t follow
the story as much as I thought I did or they weren’t clear on the passage of
time in this version.
But that’s not nearly as big a deal to me as the moral of
the story. All the conflict goes away
when Sandy changes herself and her values to match Danny’s. What relationship will last when you change
that much for someone? What’s even worse
is that from the very beginning, Danny and his friends are shown as shallow
teens who degrade women. Trust me, they
will not have a healthy relationship.
And we even get an object lesson in how they treat women with a
storyline involving Rizzo. Considering I
hear “Never change for a man” preached to teenage women, I’m surprised this is
such a popular musical since it has the exact opposite moral.
So I guess I’m one of the few who will never be a fan of
this story. For a new generation, this
product is fun, but the moral keeps me from fully recommending Grease Live!
Did you miss the part where Danny changes for Sandy by lettering in track? By both attempting to become what they think the other wants, they realize the depth of their commitment, and live happily ever after.
ReplyDelete