Wednesday, July 7, 2021

Book Review: Pint of No Return by Dana Mentink (Shake Shop Mysteries #1)

Stars: 4 out of 5
Pros: Wonderful characters, good mystery
Cons: Pacing a couple of times, took a bit of time to fully connect to story
The Bottom Line:
Opening new shop
Must clear a surprising friend
Lovely characters

Delicious Debut

July is National Ice Cream Month.  With that in mind, when Pint of No Return, the first Shake Shop Mystery from Dana Mentink crossed my radar, I knew I had to enjoy it this month.

Trinidad Jones has just gone through a divorce from a man she thought she loved but didn’t know at all.  Turned out he was thrice-married and an embezzler.  Now, he’s in prison, and all he’s left her is a storefront in the small town of Upper Sprocket, Oregon, his home town.  Despite the fact that both of his other ex-wives are also in town, Trinidad decides to move there and open her dream shop – a place called Shimmy and Shake Shop.  She intends to make her own home-made ice cream and create mammoth shakes.

Since getting the shop ready to open has taken up most of her time, she hasn’t spent too much time getting to know anyone in town.  One of the few people she has met is Kevin Heartly, the man who owns the gourmet popcorn shop opposite her new store.  One afternoon, she finds Kevin dead in the back of his shop.  The police are quick to zero in on Juliette, one of Trinidad’s fellow ex-wives.  She just met Juliette, but she doesn’t think the woman is a killer.  Can Trinidad trust her instincts?  If she is right, can she free Juliette?

I was at once drawn into this book but also felt a little on the outside.  Let me explain.  While the setting came to life, I felt like it was missing some details to make it fully real.  For example, we learn early on that Trinidad intends to open her shop on July Fourth, but we don’t get any idea how far away that is.  You know me and timelines, but that is just one example.  Still, it was those little things that kept me from fully getting lost in the world.

On the other hand, the characters are fantastic.  Is Trinidad’s relationship with Juliette believable?  Maybe or maybe not in real life, but I completely bought it in this book.  Trinidad is still meeting people, so as she gets to know those people, we do to.  And I loved those relationships.  The people helped draw me into the book more than anything else, and I loved spending time with them.

The plot is good.  The pacing was a bit off at times, but it all came together at the end and kept my interest as I read.

The book does a good job of balancing the tone.  At times, it is light and fluffy like newly mixed-up ice cream.  But it has more serious moments, too.  It holds together very well.

I enjoyed the slight twist on the classic cozy set up.  Trinidad may be starting her life over again after some disappointments and setbacks, but she didn’t run home.  I’m interested to see how that choice plays out in future books.

Of course, there are plenty of scenes involving ice cream.  I love ice cream, so my mouth was watering as I read.  If you enjoy ice cream, too, you’ll want to sample the key lime ice cream recipe at the end of the book.

Pint of No Return is a solid debut.  I will definitely be back to visit these new friends again.


I bought a copy of this book and then won one in a giveaway, so I’m passing my spare copy on to someone.  To enter the giveaway, leave me a comment telling me your favorite flavor of ice cream and your email address.  Since this is a physical copy, US only please.  I’ll pick a winner on July 14th, so enter before then.


  1. I love most ice cream no matter what flavor. But my go to is chocolate peanut butter.

  2. Jamoca Almond Fudge is my favorite flavor of ice cream.

    LOVE Dana's books and would love the opportunity to read "Pint of No Return". Shared but hoping to be the very fortunate one selected. Thanks for the chance!
    2clowns at arkansas dot net

  3. Strawberry with strawberry chunks is my favorite.

    Jrparkfan at hotmail dot com

  4. Chocolate cookie crumble, from the Kroger brand, is great.


  5. I am a simple lady, I like Vanilla soft serve with rainbow sprinkle (or even no sprinkles).

    Thank you for the opportunity to enter ��


  6. I've yet to meet an ice cream that didn't call my name. I guess my favorite is neopolitan since you have the pleasure of three in one. robeader53(at)yahoo(dot)com

  7. I love Ben and Jerry's Phish Food. Thanks so much for this giveaway! aut1063(at)gmail(dot)com

  8. Butter pecan or pistachio or pretty much any flavor. This is a new author to me. Thanks for the giveaway! JLXSTITCH (at) GMAIL (dot) COM

  9. I love strawberry shortcake ice cream but maple walnut is probably my all time favorite. Cindy226 (at) gmail (dot) com

  10. This looks super cute and is a new author to me. Pacing always seems to be an issue in the first book of the series. Maybe because of all the setup? I've noticed that quite a bit. And I've been on a big Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough binge lately! I'm going to skip the giveaway because I'm trying to clear some room on my shelves but I'll add this to my TBR for future purposes!

  11. How nice of you! I have been trying to win this book! My favorite ice cream is Mocha Almond Fudge! Thanks for this chance! lindaherold999(at)gmail(dot)com

  12. I love Peanut butter and chocolate. Baskin Robbins does a great job! Would love to read this. Thanks for the chance! cherierj at yahoo dot com

  13. My favorite flavor is Blue Bell Homemade Vanilla. It's perfect with everything. 3labsmom(at)gmail(dot)com

  14. Mint chocolate chip for the Win! 😊

  15. Sounds fun! I have to admit I love ice cream too. Yesterday I had a scoop of pretzel peanut butter and a scoop of extreme oreo.