Monday, January 18, 2016

Book Review: Murder Most Finicky by Liz Mugavero (Pawsitively Organic Mysteries #4)

Stars: 5 out of 5
Pros: Memorable characters and a complicated mystery
Cons: Most series regulars only get cameos
The Bottom Line:
Pastry chef’s death
Complicates foodie weekend
New setting still fun

Only a Finicky Reader Wouldn’t Love This Book

Two of the biggest themes in the cozy mystery world are pet cozies and culinary cozies.  Expertly balancing the world between the two is Liz Mugavero, whose main character creates organic treats and meals for pets.  Murder Most Finicky is the fourth book in the series, and it’s another winner.

Kristan “Stan” Connor has agreed to participate in a culinary weekend in Rhode Island with famed chef Sheldon Allyn.  Sheldon is looking to put together a great group of chefs he works with to pull off an impressive dinner for a potential group of investors, one of whom has a cat.  If they are happy, there might be a Food Network show for all of them plus money to help Stan expand her Pawsitively Organic pet treat business.

The location of the weekend is top secret; in fact, everyone is blindfolded on their way there.  The only chef missing for the grand unveiling is pastry expert Pierre LaPorte, but Stan quickly finds him with his throat slit.  How did he find out the top secret location?  Who else knew where it was in order to kill him?  Those are just the beginning of the questions as more and more strange things happen.  Can Stan survive long enough to figure things out?

The book is mostly set in Rhode Island, and the supporting characters we have come to love over the previous three books are still at home in Connecticut.  To be perfectly honest, I missed them.  We did get some updates on them via phone calls, but they aren’t as prevalent as normal.  That’s my only complaint with the book, and it’s a minor one.  Still, I’m hoping we are back to Frog Ledge, Connecticut, and all of our friends there in the next book.

To make up for that loss, this book is filled with a wonderful cast of suspect characters.  They are all a bit larger than life, but frankly that added to the fun.  It also made it easy to remember who they all were as the plot progressed.  We do get to learn more about Stan as we watch her in this different setting, so fans of the series will appreciate that character development.

Speaking of character development, I do need to amend one thing I said earlier.  One of the series regulars does wind up showing up for several chapters.  The result is some major character development for this character, and I loved that aspect of this book.  I think it will change how Stan interacts with him or her in the future, and I’m looking forward to seeing that.  (And no, I don’t think I could have been more vague on who it is.)

The mystery continues to twist and turn in many unexpected directions before we reach the climax.  I had no clue how everything was going to be resolved until we got there.  Yet, when the villain is revealed, the clues fell perfectly into place.

Even though most of the chefs in this book make food for humans, the recipes in the back are still treats for pets.  And yes, they still sound delicious.  I think they are healthier than most of the recipes in the culinary cozies I read, too.  So if you make these for your pets and sneak a few for yourself, I won’t tell anyone.

If you love pets, you really need to read this series, but loving pets is not a requirement to enjoy this book.  Anyone who loves a good mystery should read Murder Most Finicky.

If you are interested in more of Stan's adventures, here are the Pawsitively Organic Mysteries in order.


  1. This series is on my TBR though I haven't actually read any yet. It does sound like a lot of fun and I'm glad that even though the setting is away from home it was still enjoyable. I'm now curious about the recipes!

    1. You've got to find time to bump this series up your TBR pile.

  2. Great post, thank you for sharing your thoughts.

  3. This does sound like a really fun series! Great to know about some cozy mysteries set in New England.

    1. Many more to come. Hope you enjoy this series.

  4. I think the pet treat recipes appeals to me most. I love finding neat things to do for my furbabies!

    1. There have been recipes in all four books, and they sure do sound good.

  5. oh a book set in RI (where I work!) Great! I'm not too much into cozy mysteries but make it sound good! thanks for the review Mark

    1. You're welcome. I hope if you do read this book, you enjoy it.


Thanks for stopping by. In order to combat spam, I moderate most comments. I'll get to your comment as soon as I can.